Menu

Blue Sky Computing – Dissipating the Cloud

An Analyst Insight document published by Nick Castellina of the Aberdeen Group in March 2013 prompted me to speak up for the silent cloudless majority.

An Analyst Insight document published by Nick Castellina of the Aberdeen Group in March 2013 prompted me to speak up for the silent cloudless majority. Although Mr. Castellina is careful not to make bold affirmations supporting Cloud computing (through the frequent use of many non-committal wiggle words and free associations), he does offer up many gratuitous enunciations that warrant comment.

The first of these is the fact that the author offers no definition of cloud computing, but instead presents two definitions that he (loosely and wrongfully) associates with cloud computing. Paraphrasing the study:

“SaaS or On Demand: The software itself is not …owned… (is) provided as a service…on a subscription basis. SaaS avoids a large upfront capital investment. This deployment method is one form of the Public Cloud”

“Hosted: Also considered part of the cloud, licensed applications are hosted by a third party.”

You can see the use of wiggle expressions “one form of” and “considered part of” the cloud does nothing to persuade anyone that the cloud is anything more than a loose virtual construct. Fact is hosted applications where around in the 80’s, where many business applications resided on mainframes, and applications (e.g. payroll) were deployed to guest users through telephone lines, modems and dumb terminals. With the client/server technologies that followed, nothing prevented any organization from having even legacy applications hosted off site at a third party’s location, and deployed through Citrix or terminal server technology, to computers or dumb terminals, using the internet or T1 lines as a conduit. My point is that the hosted part of what is associated with the cloud is not limited to applications with web interfaces.

As for SaaS, it has to do with finance. You don’t buy the software up-front, you just rent it. Similar to a car lease, except that the car lease has the advantage of having an end of payment date. It’s actually more like renting a water heater. You pay monthly, forever. Again this has absolutely nothing to do with web interface applications.

To strengthen this case, many supposed cloud applications can be purchased in the traditional way, and deployed on premise if that’s what the customer wants. Hosting and method of payment have very little, if anything at all, to do with the cloud.

Another train of thought worthy of comment is the author’s (weak) attempt to explain manufacturer’s resistance to Cloud computing by offering the following three possible explanations:

1. Misinformation to the effect that cloud computing is not as secure: To manufacturers, this is not misinformation. Where there is smoke…there is fire. Cloud computing has that stigma because most applications offered in cloud deployment are indeed deployed on server farms owned by very large data centres. Most of these companies have redundancy capabilities (an equally large server farm capable of hosting applications in the event of failure at the first location) located offshore. To a convenience store or small law firm, no big deal. To manufacturers who compete with Asia (and have seen production off-shored for many years), different story. The idea that, one day, their whole system and data could reside in Asia, is a risk. Many of these countries have completely different sets of rules than North Americans have when it comes to intellectual property. To North American manufacturers, this is a needless risk.

2. Manufacturers may not be aware of cloud computing’s benefits: Owners of small and medium sized manufacturers all have a solid understanding of concepts such as capital investments and ROI. All these laggards the study refers to, who have owned systems for 7 to 15 years, may not all be on the latest tech, but they finished paying for their system in the same year they bought them a decade ago. Presenting rentals to them will hardly be perceived as a benefit. Quite the contrary, manufacturers quickly come to the conclusion that the only group benefiting from SaaS are the software companies, who get a steady, never ending revenue stream.

3. Manufacturers may have a change-resistant culture: I will concede this. Many do. And it has served them well. But when there is value, they also recognize it. Improvements in robotics and other advanced manufacturing technologies that have value are adopted by manufacturers large and small when the ROI is real.

There are other advantages of on premise computing that are not discussed here, including the flexibility to decide on the timing of an upgrade; another is the greater freedom to customize; last but not least, robustness and reliability (you cannot be both new, and have withstood the test of time).

Web based applications have a lot of promise. Greater ease of use, navigation ability, and multiple device deployment can all facilitate business system adoption rates and user productivity. If it is serious about penetrating the manufacturing segment, the cloud community would do well to focus on these areas, rather than continue its futile attempts at clouding the computing issue.

Up Next
  • The Invisible Factory: Whitepaper
    The Invisible Factory: Whitepaper
  • PlantGauge Data Sheet
    PlantGauge Data Sheet
  • Software Data Sheet
    Software Data Sheet
  • Distribution Suite Data Sheet
    Distribution Suite Data Sheet
  • Project Manufacturing Data Sheet
    Project Manufacturing Data Sheet
  • PlantCare Overview
    PlantCare Overview
  • PlantUp! Datasheet
    PlantUp! Datasheet
  • SteppingStones Overview
    SteppingStones Overview
  • Inventory Control and Costing
    Inventory Control and Costing
  • Manufacturing CRM
    Manufacturing CRM
  • Production and Scheduling
    Production and Scheduling
  • Procurement and Materials
    Procurement and Materials
  • Sales Management
    Sales Management
  • Make-to-Order Make-to-Stock
    Altron Automation Achieves Precision and Cost Savings
    Altron Automation halved purchasing costs and reached 99.5% inventory accuracy by upgrading to INDUSTRIOS ERP, enabling real-time inventory management, automated job tracking, and data-driven process improvements for scalable, efficient growth.
    Altron Automation, a leading Michigan-based systems integrator for the automotive and heavy truck industries, transformed its operations by upgrading its INDUSTRIOS custom manufacturing ERP.
    Read Success Story
    Make-to-Order Make-to-Stock
    AMPCO Sustains Growth and Efficiency with INDUSTRIOS ERP
    AMPCO doubled sales and maintained fast lead times by upgrading to INDUSTRIOS ERP, absorbing vendor cost increases, reducing production delays, and improving quoting accuracy—enabling efficient, customer-focused growth.
    American Metal Products Company (AMPCO), a Portland-based tube bending and metal forming specialist, doubled sales over three years while maintaining fast lead times and competitive pricing
    Download Success Story
    Make-to-Order
    Cam Tran Modernizes Operations, Achieves 80% Payroll Time Savings
    Cam Tran upgraded to INDUSTRIOS ERP, cutting payroll processing time by 80% and automating data tracking. Real-time production monitoring and lean-ready workflows now drive efficiency, collaboration, and scalable growth.
    Cam Tran Co. Ltd., a leading North American transformer manufacturer, modernized its payroll and production processes by upgrading to the latest INDUSTRIOS ERP.
    Download Success Story
    Make-to-Order Make-to-Stock
    Real-Time Inventory and Scheduling Power Leone Fence’s Growth
    Leone Fence increased customer satisfaction by 40% through real-time inventory visibility, automated subcontractor scheduling, and seamless ERP integration, enabling proactive purchasing, accurate order tracking, and scalable growth.
    Leone Fence, the largest commercial and industrial fence installer in the Greater Toronto Area, transformed its operations by integrating INDUSTRIOS with Sage 300 ERP.
    Download Success Story
    Project Manufacturing
    Plas-Tech Automates Job Tracking and Inventory for Greater Efficiency
    Plas-Tech Inc. improved inventory accuracy and automated job tracking with INDUSTRIOS ERP, enabling real-time material visibility, data-driven cost analysis, and streamlined reporting to support efficient, scalable growth.
    Plas-Tech Inc., a custom plastic fabrication company in Concord, Ontario, transformed its operations by implementing INDUSTRIOS ERP.
    Read Success Story
    Make-to-Order
    Pratt & Larson Unifies Inventory and Shipping with INDUSTRIOS
    Pratt & Larson unified inventory and shipping with INDUSTRIOS, enabling real-time tracking, seamless workflows, and faster order fulfillment that improved accuracy, financial clarity, and client satisfaction across artisan tile production.
    Pratt & Larson Ceramics, a premier artisan tile manufacturer, transformed its operations with INDUSTRIOS custom manufacturing ERP.
    Download Success Story
    Make-to-Stock
    SmithCo Manufacturing Automates Labor & Payroll with INDUSTRIOS ERP
    SmithCo Manufacturing automated labor tracking and payroll with INDUSTRIOS ERP, gaining real-time job cost visibility, and streamlining production management. Seamless integration boosted efficiency, accuracy, and positioned SmithCo for continued growth.
    SmithCo Manufacturing, a leading producer of side dump trailers in Le Mars, Iowa, transformed its operations by implementing INDUSTRIOS ERP. Key achievements include:
    Read Success Story
    Make-to-Order
    UMC Optimizes Shipping and Inventory with INDUSTRIOS
    Universal Motion Components (UMC) streamlined shipping and improved inventory planning with INDUSTRIOS ERP. Enhanced data access and automated purchasing enable faster, more accurate deliveries, and support operational growth.
    Universal Motion Components (UMC), based in Costa Mesa, California, is a leading supplier of drive line components for the agriculture and construction industries.
    Download Success Story
    Make-to-Stock
    Universal Stenciling Grows Efficiently with INDUSTRIOS ERP
    Universal Stenciling streamlined inventory and accelerated order fulfillment using INDUSTRIOS ERP. They now fulfill 90% of orders within 24 hours and manage over 3,000 raw materials with accuracy.
    Universal Stenciling & Marking Systems, a family-owned innovator in marking, stenciling, and coding equipment since 1904, leveraged INDUSTRIOS ERP to:
    Download Success Story
    Harnessing the power of employee engagement through real time metrics

    Explore the concept of the employee engagement and how technology can impact adoption of practices that foster employee engagement. Jacques Decarie, Vice-President of Sales and Marketing with INDUSTRIOS and Jenice Rideout, President of HR Navigation Inc. provide an overview of how to apply practices to drive your team to exceptional performance.

    What's New - Handling Order to Cash processes with INDUSTRIOS

    This webinar provides an overview of how INDUSTRIOS can help you handle business processes from the time an order is received to the point where it is converted to cash. Areas covered include: Navigation, Customers, Sales Orders, Shipping and Reporting.

    What's New - Inventory Control and Costing

    Eva DeGasperis, Principal at Industrios, and Jacques Decarie, Vice President of Sales and Marketing, take a deep dive into inventory control and costing. Hear Eva talk quantity constraints, unit tracking, cost elements, valuation methods, and much, much more.

    Webinar: How the Invisible Factory will help get you back on course

    As owner of a manufacturing company, you shouldn’t be on the shop floor. You’re needed at the helm, steering the business to where it needs to go. From software to human resources, here’s what IndustriOS’ Invisible Factory can do for you.

    Webinar: INDUSTRIOS on the Cloud

    Jacques Decarie, INDUSTRIOS, and Joe Cudzik, Expedient, explain your cloud options and address your questions about ERP. You’ll learn about accessibility 24/7 on any device, enhanced security, disaster recovery and much more.

    ERP Business Benefits for Manufacturers
    Practical Business Intelligence for Manufacturers